Cow size in regards to feed efficiency

WildRoseBeef

Range nerd & bovine enthusiast
Joined
Feb 1, 2009
Messages
2,253
Reaction score
361
Points
313
Location
Alberta, Canada
It was really interesting for me to find out that the terms "grass-fed genetics" and smaller-the-better in terms of raising cattle on just grass is not exactly what it's made out to be. It's logical to think that the smaller the cow, the less feed it takes to feed her, and in the case of grass-based systems, the smaller the cow the more efficient she will be. Unfortunately, that's all marketing hype. The fact is, not all cows are made equal, and that goes for miniature, low-lined or small framed cattle too. Indeed, how well a cow or heifer or steer or bull will do on grass is due to genetics, but environmental factors also have a huge impact on them as well. For instance, frame 6 Simmentals would do well on pasture that is lush and is high in protein for most of the growing season. However, they will starve to death if you put them on sparse, coarse pasture like that in West Texas even with a few pounds of range cubes fed once or twice a day. A Frame 4 Texas Longhorn would get way too fat on the same pasture that the Simmentals do well on without supplementation.

I've read about someone having some small cattle that end up doing worse than what they initially thought they would. These cattle had to eat more in order to maintain condition, and grew too slow, in comparison to other types, sometimes larger-framed cattle fed on the same ration or in the same pasture. Genetics infused into this "grass-based" genetic herd from a line or breed that has the desirable feed efficiency produced calves that were more growthy, and easier doing than what that person initially started with.

If you want to have a grass-based cow-herd, don't get caught up in the "smaller is better" mentality. Quite often producers want small cattle only for personal reasons, nothing to do with what they are interested in terms of efficiency or low-cost production: small cattle are chosen because they feel intimidated by those that are too tall or big for their taste. What you need to do in order to select cattle that are going to be great on grass is to cull those that are hard-doing, or have to eat a lot to maintain weight. Body condition score is the best indicator as to how much a hard keeper a cow or heifer is. Another indicator is how well the offspring does on forage alone, as far as ADG is concerned. You might think you would need a scale for this, but that's not always the case. What condition calves are in is just as reliable an indicator as with cows: either by eye, or by touch when they're in the chute when you have to vaccinate them before weaning. If you're really good you can tell just by eyeing them up what their weight is, but quite often a person can under or even over-estimate their weight. This is where a good scale comes in for a more accurate measurement.

Gut capacity is another indicator on feed efficiency. A cow needs to have a large rumen in order to be able to efficiently digest the grass that she eats. For one producer I read about that lives up north from where I am has cows that look like they are barrels on four legs. (I can't imagine what these same cows look like when heavily pregnant!) Of course, gut capacity has to coincide with body condition score at the end of the day in order to see if a cow on grass and hay only is efficient on feed.

Anyway, that's some hopefully useful information that I learned about this week I thought I would share with you all. :)
 

Snowhunter

Ridin' The Range
Joined
Jul 14, 2010
Messages
197
Reaction score
12
Points
64
Location
Homer, GA
I know exactly what you're sayin! We've got cows here that are big, small and everything inbetween. The one constant, is all the big barreled deep chested girls are the easiest keepers. They do fine on just grass and hay.

We've done some serious culling this year, based on whos done the best on grass and hay with only minerals supplemented. We went from over 100+ head to 15. Those that are left are big barreled, wide bodied easy keepers. They have flourished. Some of the gals are over 5ft at the withers, some are barely 4ft, but they all do very well on grass and hay alone, even with the awful grazing we've had with this drought.

Even my Jersey cow does very well on grass and hay alone, only supplemented with minimal grain due to the crappy hay we've got (and no grass right now :he )

I'm hoping we can keep this going and start really growing the herd size in a few years. It takes patience, but its worth it when you see the results of your hard work.
 

jhm47

True BYH Addict
Joined
Sep 26, 2008
Messages
1,390
Reaction score
178
Points
228
Location
Extreme NE South Dakota
I have a few cows that are not what I would describe as "easy" keepers. However, they are cows that routinely wean calves that are 65% - 75% of the cow's weight. These cows are great milkers, and their calves are almost always the biggest in the pasture. The cows are thin, and sometimes don't breed back on their first heat. Still, their calves are usually the biggest, fattest ones in the pasture. I do try to supplement these cows a bit before winter sets in so they will have some cover on them when the coldest days hit. I agree that these cows don't look very pretty, and they may cost more to maintain, but at the price of feeder calves, I can live with their shortcomings. JMHO!
 

WildRoseBeef

Range nerd & bovine enthusiast
Joined
Feb 1, 2009
Messages
2,253
Reaction score
361
Points
313
Location
Alberta, Canada
jhm47 said:
I have a few cows that are not what I would describe as "easy" keepers. However, they are cows that routinely wean calves that are 65% - 75% of the cow's weight. These cows are great milkers, and their calves are almost always the biggest in the pasture. The cows are thin, and sometimes don't breed back on their first heat. Still, their calves are usually the biggest, fattest ones in the pasture. I do try to supplement these cows a bit before winter sets in so they will have some cover on them when the coldest days hit. I agree that these cows don't look very pretty, and they may cost more to maintain, but at the price of feeder calves, I can live with their shortcomings. JMHO!
Ain't that something? The ones that look like crap will often be the ones that will throw the best calves, over the ones that look like a bunch of beauty queens. Whether it's due to genetics, great ability to put their resources into growing a calf, or what is something I'd love to know. It's probably the latter, but :idunno .
 

kfacres

New Member
Joined
May 21, 2012
Messages
271
Reaction score
3
Points
0
WildRoseBeef said:
jhm47 said:
I have a few cows that are not what I would describe as "easy" keepers. However, they are cows that routinely wean calves that are 65% - 75% of the cow's weight. These cows are great milkers, and their calves are almost always the biggest in the pasture. The cows are thin, and sometimes don't breed back on their first heat. Still, their calves are usually the biggest, fattest ones in the pasture. I do try to supplement these cows a bit before winter sets in so they will have some cover on them when the coldest days hit. I agree that these cows don't look very pretty, and they may cost more to maintain, but at the price of feeder calves, I can live with their shortcomings. JMHO!
Ain't that something? The ones that look like crap will often be the ones that will throw the best calves, over the ones that look like a bunch of beauty queens. Whether it's due to genetics, great ability to put their resources into growing a calf, or what is something I'd love to know. It's probably the latter, but :idunno .
that's b/c their intake goes to output... compare almost any dairy animal to any beef animal.. which one will be fatter, and which one will give more milk.

heavy milkers are not desired in harsh environments.
 

Latest posts

Top