So I talked it over with my family and nobody has the time or energy to fight a ewe several times a day for several weeks. I didn't realize it might take longer than a few days, and every time we put the lamb in there the mom was slamming her across the pen. Plus with our grazing system we're moving them to fresh grass every two days right now which makes keeping the mom penned up very difficult. It would be stressful for me, stressful for the ewe and both lambs and stressful for my family.
All that to say, we have a bottle baby lamb now.

Her name is Hope, and she will probably stay. I love her mom (though I love her a bit less now for putting me through this....) so she will hopefully be a breeding ewe for me and I think she will also have a job like Spot in a couple months come weaning time! We already have so many bottle baby goats that one more doesn't make that big of a difference. I already got almost a quart of colostrum from her mom to feed her.
Hope is already incredibly spoiled and taking naps in everyone's laps. She's living in the bottle baby pen, I bet she'll think she's a goat before long.
View attachment 116644