- Thread starter
- #831
Southern by choice
Herd Master
I agree with the "universal" thing. Luckily they have not tried to make our show breeds of chickens all alike. And the Standard of Perfection specifically states how each breed should look. There are still some changes over the years, in some breeds, but not like in the cattle and I guess, the goat breeds.
There are a few beef breeders that have been looking for, and going back to, the older genetics to try to get some of the "real breed characteristics" back in the cattle. Genetics have become so refined that they are using all this "genomics" which means that " IN THEORY" this bull A bred to this cow B will produce superior off spring. They are using that to the detriment of losing some of the other good characteristics...like longevity.... Supposedly they can determine which bulls will throw heifers that will be more likely to have high cell counts (mastitis tendencies) and such. They are flushing virgin heifers at 12-14 months, to young bulls that are out of virgin heifers....No milk records for the dam of the bull and sometimes not the granddam.... but his "genomics" say he will sire super duper high producing heifers..... Guess it doesn't make a big difference because the average time a cow is in a productive dairy farm is less than 2 lactations.
And in the catalogs you haven't been able to see a picture of the bull you are buying semen from for years. But in the experts opinion he is superior...
It is very interesting because the system used for cattle (from what I understand) was adapted for goats. Between milktest and Linear Appraisal it seems that goats are getting bred all by the numbers.
Although I do feel there is merit to the programs and can be a "tool" used in predictability the bottom line goats are goats. Some lines just don't match up well. Period!
After doing milktest this year... ummmm.... can I just say I will never look at milk numbers the same way. I hope to write about our experience soon. It has been the worlds worst first year milktest in the history of milktest. Where you laugh because you just cannot believe what you are going through.
I agree with losing some very important characteristics as well. There are many many people out there that don't like the newer "style" of Lamancha.
Maybe because I am older, maybe because I see things from a different perspective, maybe because I am stubborn, I like to LOOK at a goat. If I like the goat then I do. If I don't , I don't.
I am a fan of breed what you like. That doesn't minimize the factors that will help improve areas that need improved. But in the end Goat A bred to Goat B "should" produce this and that... trust me... that is not always the case. It doesn't mean either goat was a bad goat- they simply just didn't line up. It's crushing but it happens.
I also notice there are so many name hoppers/chasers that they will get that animal with that "name" and yet that animal may very well end up being exactly what you don't want.