Waste Hay and Alfalfa Stems

duffontap

Chillin' with the herd
Joined
Mar 20, 2011
Messages
65
Reaction score
0
Points
29
It is universally known among goat people that our buddies waste hay. But, after a couple years of having goats I still twitch when I see one of the goats grab a huge mouthful of hay or alfalfa and watch 60% of it fall on the ground while they chew it. We have a modified keyhole feeder to help limit waste, which is something we can get away with since we only keep 2-4 goats at a time (and they're Oberhaslis so they get along like angels :D ), but we still throw away what seems like mountains of hay because it touches the ground and the goats won't touch it anymore. Additionally, two hours after I throw a large flake of fresh orchard grass or timothy into the feeder, there is a fluffy mound of loose hay piled above the feeder that is left from the goats picking through and eating all the leafy parts and leaving the stemmy parts. At this point, the goats will nibble at what's left, but they have to be pretty hungry to eat everything in the feeder.

What I'm wondering is, how much hay are you others willing to throw out? Do you make your milking does eat the alfalfa stems, or just the nutrient-dense leaves? Do you wait until the feeder is empty to refill it, or do you regularly or occasionally empty the feeder and throw out the leftovers, or use them as bedding?

At the moment, we only have two goats so this isn't a financial issue--the milk and companionship more than pays for their food. We're mostly curious about what the more experienced goat herders are doing.
 

PattySh

Loving the herd life
Joined
Apr 7, 2010
Messages
1,108
Reaction score
11
Points
104
Location
Northwest Vermont
I don't feed alfalfa but the wasted grass hay under the feeders goes to our cow or horses or is thrown to the pigs for bedding. Nothing wasted here :).
 

SuburbanFarmChic

Overrun with beasties
Joined
May 31, 2011
Messages
1,650
Reaction score
7
Points
89
Location
WV - Eastern Panhandle
We have 8 goats/sheep and a mix of breeds and ages. Ours get a big junk round bale to nibble and play king of the mountain on and then they I have a hay racks, 1 inside and 1 outside, that I split a square bale between. They also have pasture/browse stuff. They have to pretty much finish off a square bale to get another tossed in there. What they truly won't eat goes to the chickens.
 

SDGsoap&dairy

Loving the herd life
Joined
Dec 7, 2009
Messages
2,829
Reaction score
8
Points
119
Location
North Georgia
When my bucks aren't getting much alfalfa (they're getting plenty right now because they're in rut and burning calories) I pull the stems out of the doe feeder and give them to the bucks. Because their alfalfa is limited and they don't have a choice about picking out the leafy bits they snarf the stems. During the cooler months we purchase bermuda round bales. We store it where they can't get on it and just stuff it in the manger by the armload. It's far cheaper per pound, so they can waste as much as they like. Then we feed as much alfalfa as they will consume without wasting it like crazy.
 

freemotion

Self Sufficient Queen
Joined
May 19, 2009
Messages
3,271
Reaction score
22
Points
236
Location
Western MA
A bale of straw here costs almost what a bale of good hay costs, and more than cheap hay. Wasted hay is bedding. I also do all my gardens, lawn, and pasture organically so there is never enough compost with only five goats, so I no longer resent wasted hay. I still have less compost with 5+ goats (kids part of the year) than I did with one horse, although the horse did not waste hay, there was a LOT of purchased bedding required and a lot of stall cleaning to do, even in a run-in shed situation. So it all works out.

On the rare occasion when I can get my hands on a few bales of straight alfalfa, I shake out the flakes in a big tub and put the stems in the racks. They get the precious leaf in feed tubs. But I have a tiny herd.
 

duffontap

Chillin' with the herd
Joined
Mar 20, 2011
Messages
65
Reaction score
0
Points
29
I'm amazed at how diverse and resourceful you all are. Yesterday, for the first time, we took some spent hay and bedding to the transfer station. With our small property, we just can't seem to compost it fast enough to use it in the gardens. Thanks for your thoughts! JD
 

20kidsonhill

True BYH Addict
Joined
Jan 7, 2011
Messages
6,246
Reaction score
118
Points
243
Location
Virgnia
I don't find any hay wasted is acceptable, straw is a much cheaper bedding,we have built our hay feeders with this in mind, and we have very little wasted hay. I also only feed what they clean up in between feedings, which are AM and PM feedings. It is pretty much free-choice, since I don't want it to run out right away, just want it to be gone by the next feeding.

OUr hay feeders are a little work to build but, have held up for years, and since they don't waste hay, they pay for themselves over time. A little heavy to move around, we normally slip them on a bucket of our small garden tractor, but my husband and I can relocate one by ourselves in need be, slowly, but we can.

photos is of the outside of it, facing out of the pen, where we put the hay in,
3140_167302_116615598410299_100001855770147_122604_3781053_n.jpg




Inside of it where the goats eat out of, The bottom pan can also be used to feed grain, but it needs to be scraped before putting the grain in it. Hay always leaves a little dirt behind.

3140_nibbleslabor3.jpg



two feeders lined up with dividing boards coming out 8 feet, to keep does from fighting, "We average 20 does.
3140_jan_2011_096.jpg
 

aggieterpkatie

The Shepherd
Joined
Oct 23, 2009
Messages
3,696
Reaction score
11
Points
156
I get very little waste with alfalfa when I feed outside, since it is very similar to one of these style feeders and they clean up leaves that fall in the pan. Plus, if I see they still have any hay in their feeder I'll wait to feed more until they finish it. I do get more waste in the winter since I mostly feed in their shelter and those feeders are modified wall hay feeders for horses (with horizontal bars welded in so they don't waste as much), but since it's in the shelter that's my primary bedding (with straw added as needed).
 

duffontap

Chillin' with the herd
Joined
Mar 20, 2011
Messages
65
Reaction score
0
Points
29
I have got to build a new feeder! Thanks for the inspiration. I'll post pics here when I get around to building it. :)
 
Top