Well, we cleaned both ears. It was pretty easy with a pocketful of alfalfa pellets! Little chowhound!
I squirted 3 cc of peroxide/water into each ear and dh held her so she couldn't shake while I massaged the ears and stuffed her with alfalfa pellets. Then I cleaned with gauze squares first and got a couple of chunks of wax from the ear in question, just some wax color from the other ear. I could get my little finger in there with her being well restrained. It looked like normal ear wax to me, like would come from my own ear. I got right up to her ear and took a couple of good sniffs....nothing, nothing but sweet goat face smell. I went in with a swab, carefully, and got nothing other than normal wax color on the cotton. No smell from either ear.
I'm thinking it was just a gob of wax? It was the goopy texture that still concerns me, but I am far less concerned now.
When we let her go, she shook a bit, and all that I saw come out was the peroxide. I watched her for a bit after letting her back out in the sunshine, and she shook a couple more times, but didn't look uncomfortable. No more goop came out. Hmmmm.