These things happen. Just take hm to the sale yard. Meat buyers won't care that he has only one eye. There are always lots of bucks around.
Are you testing the whole flock for Scrapie Codon 171? If you have been buying your foundation stock from scrapie tagged flocks with no record of cases, I wouldn't worry about scrapie until you have larger numbers of sheep. You can also cut the possibility of scrapie in your flock by buying and breeding to RR tested rams. Or are you setting up as a RR Codon flock? If you are selling on Craigslist, Craigslist buyers seldom ask about Codon 171 testing. Are you also planning on going on NSIP?
The Scrapie Flock Certification Program (SFCP) was added in 1992 as a voluntary program for sheep and goat breeders in California. We got our tag number then. The nationwide mandatory Regulatory Scrapie Slaughter Surveillance (RSSS) started April 1, 2003. In the voluntary program you could choose the numbers or letters you wanted, i.e. CA RT1. Now the state assigns you a number prefixed by the state, i.e. TX 123. With individual state scrapie numbers being assigned to breeders, and mandatory scrapie tagging of all breeding and butcher animals, any cases that turn up in the industry are traceable back to the original seller. Since the mandatory program started the incidence of scrapies in the US has decreased about 99%. There are very few cases of scrapie in the United States now.