Womwotai
Ridin' The Range
- Joined
- Jan 31, 2014
- Messages
- 140
- Reaction score
- 92
- Points
- 73
HikerFrog, please don't be offended. I think everyone here is doing it because they get pleasure in some way from their animals and/or farm in addition to any other purpose the livestock may have. I think BossRoo only wanted to be sure you are aware that barnyard animals CAN harm you in ways that domestic pets usually can not.
I personally do pretty much think of my livestock as just that. They don't get named and each species was selected specifically for what they can provide for me - food. That is not to say I don't get enormous pleasure from them. Just yesterday I went to stand in the sheep/goat shelter for an hour in a blowing snow-storm that piled up drifts several feet high in places, watching the sheep and goats contentedly munching on their hay. Because watching them gives me pleasure.
I have friends who think of their animals as their children. They refer to themselves as "Mommy" and "Daddy" and their multiple animals will be referred to as "brother" or "sister" in reference to each other. They live in the house and wear people clothes and get people food treats. Most of all, their every interaction is interpreted as if they ARE people and while I respect each person's right to raise their animals as they wish (as long as no cruelty or neglect is involved), it is only the latter that I believe is a mistake. For example, a chicken doesn't run to you because it loves you - it's little brain isn't even capable of that emotion. It runs to you because it has learned that sometimes when you approach you carry treats and therefore it is worth running to you every time "just in case". A rooster who spurs you doesn't do it because he "hates" you - again, he isn't even capable of hate. He spurs you because he sees you as a threat to his hens, and his instinct is to protect his hens from threats. Interpreting the behavior of a dog or cat as if it is a human is usually not dangerous, but doing the same with a sheep, goat, pig, cow or horse can result in injury.
But there is nothing wrong with getting sheep or goats because you like seeing them out grazing and you want to give them names and be able to handle them. You don't have to breed them or use them for meat, milk or fiber in order to enjoy them. It is good for pasture to be grazed and have the by-products of the grazing animals added as fertilizer, so I say "go for it"
I personally do pretty much think of my livestock as just that. They don't get named and each species was selected specifically for what they can provide for me - food. That is not to say I don't get enormous pleasure from them. Just yesterday I went to stand in the sheep/goat shelter for an hour in a blowing snow-storm that piled up drifts several feet high in places, watching the sheep and goats contentedly munching on their hay. Because watching them gives me pleasure.
I have friends who think of their animals as their children. They refer to themselves as "Mommy" and "Daddy" and their multiple animals will be referred to as "brother" or "sister" in reference to each other. They live in the house and wear people clothes and get people food treats. Most of all, their every interaction is interpreted as if they ARE people and while I respect each person's right to raise their animals as they wish (as long as no cruelty or neglect is involved), it is only the latter that I believe is a mistake. For example, a chicken doesn't run to you because it loves you - it's little brain isn't even capable of that emotion. It runs to you because it has learned that sometimes when you approach you carry treats and therefore it is worth running to you every time "just in case". A rooster who spurs you doesn't do it because he "hates" you - again, he isn't even capable of hate. He spurs you because he sees you as a threat to his hens, and his instinct is to protect his hens from threats. Interpreting the behavior of a dog or cat as if it is a human is usually not dangerous, but doing the same with a sheep, goat, pig, cow or horse can result in injury.
But there is nothing wrong with getting sheep or goats because you like seeing them out grazing and you want to give them names and be able to handle them. You don't have to breed them or use them for meat, milk or fiber in order to enjoy them. It is good for pasture to be grazed and have the by-products of the grazing animals added as fertilizer, so I say "go for it"